Controversy
 

Should Dalmiya contest CAB polls?

The controversy rages

The controversy over Dalmiya’s announcement to contest the CAB presidential polls to be held in July rages on in sports circles of Kolkata and thanks to the active interest taken by the chief minister of the West Bengal, Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee in the matters of the CAB, controversy has taken a political colour.

Dalmiya is currently the president of the CAB and wants to contest the elections once again.But the police commissioner of Kolkata, Prasun Mukherjee has made his going tough by announcing his decision to contest the post of CAB’s president.

The chief minister has thrown his weight behind the police commissioner and has suggested Dalmiya to keep off the elections to make way for his successor.

Many critics of the chief minister are criticizing him for politicizing the whole issue.The former chief minister Jyoti Basu took strong exception to Buddhadeb Bhattacharya’s suggestion to Dalmiya that he should not contest the election and make way for Prasun Mukherjee in the greater interests of the sports in the state.

Here is an account of who said what on the issue:

The former footballer and Mohun Bagan coach, Amal Dutta said:

“Can you tell me what a policeman has to do with cricket? A player has to be chosen on the basis of merit and not on the canvassing of a police commissioner backed by a chief minister.Today we are seeing the chief minister interfering in cricket administration .Tomorrow he will try to do the same for football and then for other sports .The signs are ominous.”

Chunni Goswami, former football player and Olympian said:

“He ( Prasun Mukherjee ) is competent and intelligent but I doubt he will be able to do justice to the CAB in view of his role as a police commissioner.”

Former cricketer Sambaran Banerjee said :

“He has always has a keen interest in sports and has been instrumental in assisting several players across the spectrum.He would usher a new era for the CAB if elected.”

Jyoti Basu, former chief minister said:

What is the need for the police comnissionerr who has many other large responsibilities to get involved in the affairs of the CAB ?”

Forward Block state secretary Ashok Bhattacharya said :

“This is an unhealthy development.We should not interfere with CAB’s election to its president’s post.”

Buddhadeb Bhattacharya , the chief minister of West Bengal said :

“Bengal cricket is in a bad shape.No cricket match of international standard will be played in the Eden Gardens for the next two years if Dalmiya continues in office.Dalmiya being at the helm no budding cricketer of Bengal will get a chance in the national team.”


What do you have to say on this issue?Kolkatabuzz invites your comments and opinions on the controversy.Feel free to write to sohail.arshad@tiolisoftware.com


Jagmohan Dalmiya


Prasun Mukherjee



Buddhadeb Bhattacharya